U.S. Tax Traps for Non-U.S. Investors: What Foreign Owners Often Learn Too Late
By Christine Alexis Concepción, International Tax Attorney
The United States continues to attract foreign investors seeking stability, opportunity, and long-term growth. From Miami luxury real estate to operating businesses and passive investment holdings, the U.S. remains one of the most desirable destinations for international capital. Its legal protections, transparent markets, and economic resilience make it an appealing environment for individuals and families looking to preserve and grow wealth internationally. However, what many non-U.S. investors discover, often too late, is that the U.S. tax system contains hidden traps that can significantly reduce returns, create unexpected liabilities, and expose families to avoidable financial and legal risk.
As an international tax attorney advising non-U.S. individuals, foreign business owners, and cross-border families, I frequently meet clients who made sound and strategic investment decisions but did not receive (or wish to obtain) proper tax guidance before moving forward. The issue is rarely the investment itself. In most cases, the underlying asset is strong and well-chosen. The problem lies in how the investment was structured from a U.S. tax perspective. Without proper planning, foreign investors can face unnecessary income taxes, unexpected withholding requirements, complex reporting obligations, and even U.S. estate tax exposure. These consequences are often preventable with the right planning in place. Understanding these risks before investing can make the difference between preserving your returns and eroding them through avoidable tax inefficiencies.
One of the most common situations I encounter involves foreign investors purchasing U.S. real estate in their personal name. This approach often feels natural and straightforward, especially for investors who are accustomed to simpler tax systems in their home countries. However, direct ownership of U.S. real estate can create significant long-term consequences that are not immediately apparent at the time of purchase.
For example, non-U.S. individuals who directly own U.S. real estate may be subject to U.S. estate tax if they pass away while owning the property. Unlike U.S. citizens, who benefit from a substantial estate tax exemption, non-U.S. individuals often have only a $60,000 exemption on U.S.-situated assets. This means that a property purchased as a long-term investment or family asset can ultimately create a substantial and unexpected tax burden for heirs. Families are often surprised to learn that the U.S. government may impose an estate tax on U.S. real estate owned by non-residents, even when those individuals never lived in the United States.
Direct ownership also means that legal title to the property cannot be transferred to heirs automatically. Instead, a formal probate proceeding is typically required in the U.S. to recognize the heirs and authorize the transfer of ownership. Probate can be costly, time-consuming, and burdensome, particularly for foreign families unfamiliar with the U.S. legal system. It often requires local legal representation, court filings, and administrative procedures that delay the transfer and increase overall costs. Proper structuring before acquisition can help avoid probate and allow for a more efficient transfer of the property.
In addition to estate tax exposure, direct ownership can also create privacy concerns, as property ownership records are generally public. It may also limit flexibility in managing rental income, reduce tax efficiency, and complicate future disposition or succession planning. These risks are not inherent to the investment itself, but rather to the structure used to hold it. With proper structuring before acquisition, foreign investors can often significantly reduce or eliminate these exposures while preserving flexibility and control.
Even when investors successfully acquire and hold U.S. real estate, another unexpected issue frequently arises at the time of sale. Many foreign investors are surprised to learn about FIRPTA, the Foreign Investment in Real Property Tax Act. Under FIRPTA, when a non-U.S. owner sells U.S. real estate, the buyer is generally required to withhold 15% of the gross sales price, not the net gain, and remit that amount to the IRS. FIRPTA can also apply when restructuring an investment into the proper structure. While the tax may be avoidable, the legal fees to do so often exceed what it would have cost to implement the correct structure from the start.
This distinction is critical. Because the withholding is based on the total sale price (or value of the disposition) rather than the profit, investors may have a substantial portion of their proceeds withheld even if their actual tax liability is much lower. This often creates confusion and frustration, particularly for investors who expected to receive full access to their sale proceeds at closing. While it is possible to reconcile the actual tax owed and potentially recover excess withholding, doing so requires additional filings, time, and administrative effort. Proper planning in advance can help minimize disruption and ensure that investors are prepared for the process rather than caught off guard.
Beyond real estate ownership and disposition, the cross-border structure used to hold U.S. investments plays a critical role in determining overall tax efficiency. Many foreign investors establish ownership structures without fully understanding how U.S. tax law treats foreign companies, U.S. entities such as LLCs, and hybrid arrangements. What appears to be a protective or tax-efficient structure in one country may create unintended tax consequences in the United States.
An improperly structured investment can result in double taxation, increased withholding, and ongoing reporting obligations that add cost and complexity over time. Conversely, a properly designed structure can enhance tax efficiency, improve asset protection, and align with the investor’s long-term estate and succession goals. The optimal approach depends on a variety of factors, including the investor’s country of residence, tax treaty considerations, long-term plans for the asset, and family wealth planning objectives. There is no universal structure that works for every investor. Each structure must be carefully designed to reflect the investor’s unique circumstances.
In addition to structuring considerations, foreign investors are often surprised to learn that owning U.S. assets can create ongoing U.S. tax filing and reporting obligations. These obligations may exist even if the investor does not live in the United States and even if the investment generates limited income. Depending on the ownership structure and activities involved, foreign investors may be required to file U.S. tax returns, informational disclosures, and entity reporting forms.
Failure to comply with these requirements can result in significant penalties and administrative complications. Just as importantly, unresolved compliance issues can create obstacles when attempting to sell an investment, transfer ownership, or restructure holdings. Compliance is not simply a technical formality. It is an essential component of protecting both the investment and the investor’s broader financial position.
Ultimately, the most costly mistake foreign investors make is not related to any single tax rule. It is waiting too long to seek qualified advice. Once an investment has been completed, many of the most effective planning opportunities are no longer available. Attempting to restructure after the fact can trigger additional tax consequences, increase legal and administrative costs, and create unnecessary complexity. In contrast, proactive planning before acquisition allows investors to structure their holdings in a way that minimizes tax exposure, protects family wealth, and supports long-term financial goals.
If you are a non-U.S. investor planning to purchase U.S. real estate, invest in a U.S. business, or review an existing ownership structure, proper tax planning is essential. As an international tax attorney at Concepción Global, I advise foreign investors, business owners, and international families on U.S. tax structuring, compliance, and cross-border planning strategies designed to protect their investments and prevent costly surprises.
I invite you to schedule a confidential consultation to evaluate your current or planned U.S. investments and ensure your structure is optimized from the start. The best time to plan is before you invest. The next best time is now.
Contact:
Christine Alexis Concepción, International Tax Attorney
Call: +1.305.444.6669
Email: info@concepcionlaw.com
Click here to submit an inquiry using our Contact Form